MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

Tony's hurt left arm is a warning

Tony keeps injuring his left arm because the Infinity Gauntlet will ruin it, or cost him the arm.

What fans think

Fans noticed Tony's left arm gets hurt in film after film, and that he starts having trouble with it in Civil War. One r/FanTheories post argued the damage was a time echo of Tony using the gauntlet in Endgame, like the burn Thanos got after his snap. Many expected Tony to lose the arm. In Endgame the snap kills him, but he does not lose either arm.

Behind the theory

The left arm pain had a medical reading too. Pain in the left arm is a classic heart attack sign, and Tony's heart had been damaged since the shrapnel of the first Iron Man. Some fans saw the arm as a hint about his heart rather than a time echo. Source: Iron Man (2008), the cave in Afghanistan

The film's own detail goes against the theory: Tony wears the Stark-made gauntlet on his right hand, and it is the right side of his body that burns. Thanos had worn his gauntlet on the left, and his left arm is the one scarred after his snap in Infinity War. The damage follows the hand that snaps, not Tony's old injuries. Source: Avengers: Infinity War (2018), Wakanda; Avengers: Endgame (2019), Tony's snap

The evidence board

  1. Tony is hit by a tank blast and later falls about 100 feet onto his left side.

    Iron Man (2008); Captain America: Civil War
  2. Thanos's arm is burned after his snap.

    Avengers: Infinity War ending

The case against

  • Each injury has an ordinary in-story cause, and several came before The Avengers.

Debunked

Tony dies from the snap but keeps both arms; the 'time echo' never shows up.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on r/FanTheories in 2019 (u/Dolly_Bakels, per Inverse). The original post. Covered by Inverse and CinemaBlend; listed by WatchMojo among top wrong Endgame theories.

More theories about these films

The open question

Do the MCU's repeated injuries mean anything, or are fans finding patterns that aren't there?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space