MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

Natasha can come back from the Soul Stone

Black Widow's soul lives inside the Soul Stone and she can be freed or traded back.

What fans think

Natasha dies on Vormir so Clint can get the Soul Stone, and Hulk later says he tried to bring her back. One r/FanTheories post argued Hulk had seen her inside the stone, the way Thanos sees young Gamora. Others hoped Steve returning the stone would return her too. The writers ruled it out ('It's not like a pawn shop'), and Scarlett Johansson said, 'Natasha is dead. She is dead. She's dead.'

Behind the theory

On Vormir, Clint and Natasha fight each other for the right to die. She wins and falls, and Clint wakes holding the stone. Her story still went on after Endgame. Black Widow, set years earlier, ends with her sister Yelena at her grave, told by Valentina that Clint was to blame. Source: Avengers: Endgame (2019), Vormir; Black Widow (2021), post-credits scene

Hawkeye picks up that thread. Yelena tracks Clint down to kill him, and in the finale he tells her how Natasha chose to give her life. Yelena walks away, and nothing in that talk hints that Natasha can come back. Source: Hawkeye, episode 6 (Disney+, 2021)

The evidence board

  1. Thanos meets young Gamora in an orange dream world after the snap.

    Avengers: Infinity War, after the snap
  2. Hulk tells the team he tried to bring her back.

    Avengers: Endgame, after the snap

The case against

  • Markus: putting the stone back does not return anything.
  • Johansson closed the door on a return.

Debunked

The writers said returning the stone gives nothing back, and Johansson said Natasha is dead.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on r/FanTheories in 2020 (u/Crispworthy, per Inverse). The original post. Covered by Inverse, Looper, TheWrap and Newsweek.

More theories about these films

The open question

Should Natasha have been brought back, or does her sacrifice only matter if it stays?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space