MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

Teen is Agatha's lost son Nicholas

Agatha was strangely drawn to the nameless boy, and some fans said he was her dead son returned.

What fans think

Before Teen was revealed as Billy Maximoff, a rival theory said he was Nicholas Scratch, Agatha's son in the comics, who died young in the show's backstory. Fans noted that 'you're so much like your mother' could fit either boy. In episode 4 Rio tells Agatha the boy is not hers, and in episode 5 the Ouija board scene reaches Nicholas as a dead child's voice. Episode 6 names Teen as Billy.

Behind the theory

Agatha Harkness began in a 1970 Fantastic Four comic as the witch hired to babysit Franklin Richards, and her son Nicholas Scratch arrived a few years later as a villain leading the Salem Seven. The show kept Nicholas only as a lost child in Agatha's past, which is what made a hidden boy look like he could be him. Source: Fantastic Four #94 (1970), by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby; Fantastic Four #185 (1977), by Len Wein and George Perez

The evidence board

  1. The 'like your mother' line could point to Agatha as much as Wanda.

    Agatha All Along, episode 5
  2. Rio has to tell Agatha outright that the boy is not hers, showing the question was in Agatha's mind too.

    Agatha All Along, episode 4

The case against

  • The Ouija board scene treats Nicholas as dead and separate from Teen.

Debunked

Rio says he isn't Agatha's son, and episode 6 names him Billy.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on Reddit and X in 2024-09 (Twitter). Covered by ComicBook.com, Inverse, Kotaku Australia and Epicstream.

More theories about these films

The open question

Did Agatha come to care about Billy for himself, or because he reminded her of Nicholas?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space