Foggy Nelson survived Bullseye's shot
Daredevil: Born Again killed Foggy in its first episode, and fans hoped it was a trick.
What fans think
Born Again opens with Bullseye shooting Foggy Nelson at Josie's Bar. Fans hoped it was faked: maybe Foggy went into hiding or witness protection, maybe a strange glowing stone in a later episode could bring him back. Marvel TV head Brad Winderbaum then said Elden Henson would return in season 2. Charlie Cox shut the theory down in November 2025: 'Daredevil heard his heart stop. He's dead.' He added, 'I love that theory, but it's wrong.'
Behind the theory
Foggy has been Matt's partner since the first Daredevil comic in 1964, and Elden Henson played him for three seasons of Netflix's Daredevil, so his death in the first minutes of Born Again was a shock on purpose. Matt chases Bullseye onto the roof and throws him off, then the show jumps a year ahead, with Matt alone and Karen gone from New York. Source: Daredevil #1 (1964), by Stan Lee and Bill Everett; Daredevil: Born Again, episode 1 (Disney+, 2025)
The rest of the season keeps his loss in view. Matt opens a new practice without him, and Bullseye's trial and later prison scenes keep the shooting on screen. Source: Daredevil: Born Again, season 1 (Disney+, 2025)
The evidence board
Brad Winderbaum said Elden Henson is coming back for season 2.
Daredevil: Born Again, season 2 newsA glowing orange stone targeted by robbers in episode 5 made some fans think of the Soul Stone and a way back.
Daredevil: Born Again, episode 5
The case against
- The death happens on screen and the showrunner said it had to; Cox said the theory is wrong.
Debunked
Charlie Cox said plainly that Foggy is dead; reports say his season 2 return is through flashbacks.
Do you buy it?
One tap. No account needed.
Where it started
Started on Reddit and X in 2025-03 (Twitter). Covered by ComingSoon, SuperHeroHype, TechRadar, Newsweek and Inverse.
The open question
Was killing Foggy the right way to start Born Again, or did it cut the heart out of Daredevil?