The Nick Fury we've watched since 2014 is a Skrull
A joke Reddit post about toast grew into a theory that Talos replaced Fury after The Winter Soldier.
Started on Reddit, 2019-03
Strange acted strangely in the No Way Home trailer, and some fans decided he was Mysterio wearing his face.
The first No Way Home trailer showed Doctor Strange agreeing to a risky spell and the Sanctum buried in winter snow. Some fans felt he was acting out of character and argued that Quentin Beck, a master of illusions who knew Peter's secret, was posing as Strange. A related theory said he was the evil Strange from What If...? The film used the real Strange throughout; Mysterio appears only in old footage.
What If...? did not invent this Strange from nothing. Its fourth episode follows a Strange who lost Christine instead of his hands, breaks reality trying to bring her back and becomes Strange Supreme. Source: What If...?, season 1 episode 4 (Disney+, 2021)
Beck's only part in No Way Home is the fallout from his lie. The film opens right after his doctored video names Peter as Spider-Man and blames him for Beck's death, and the angry crowds and the legal case that follow are why Peter goes to Strange for a spell in the first place. Source: Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021), opening; Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019), mid-credits scene
Strange seems oddly willing to cast a dangerous spell for a teenager.
Spider-Man: No Way Home trailer, the Sanctum sceneThe snow-covered Sanctum looked strange to fans, who called it a hint of an illusion.
Spider-Man: No Way Home trailerAnother theory said this Strange had been replaced, possibly by the evil Strange from What If...?
Spider-Man: No Way Home trailer and What If...? season 1The Strange in No Way Home is the real one; Mysterio appears only in archival footage.
One tap. No account needed.
Started on Reddit and fan forums in 2021-08 (reported by Italian outlets). Covered by Movieplayer.it, BestMovie.it, The Digital Fix and MickeyBlog.
A joke Reddit post about toast grew into a theory that Talos replaced Fury after The Winter Soldier.
Started on Reddit, 2019-03
Before dying, Tony uploaded his mind, and his hologram message was that AI talking.
Started on r/FanTheories, 2019
Ned remembers Peter at the end of Brand New Day because their secret handshake undid the magic.
Fans talking since 2026
Was Strange too careless in No Way Home, or was he just being kind to a grieving kid?