MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Still open

The Nick Fury we've watched since 2014 is a Skrull

A joke Reddit post about toast grew into a theory that Talos replaced Fury after The Winter Soldier.

What fans think

In Captain Marvel, young Fury says he can't eat toast cut diagonally, a detail to prove he is not a Skrull. A Redditor noticed Fury eating a diagonally cut sandwich in Age of Ultron and suggested the Fury in later films was an impostor; another version says the real Fury was taken to space to heal after nearly dying in The Winter Soldier, with Talos filling in. Far From Home showed Talos really was posing as Fury at least once. The Captain Marvel directors joked Fury may just have changed his mind about toast.

Behind the theory

The 2014 date comes from The Winter Soldier, where Fury is shot through a wall by the Winter Soldier and fakes his death with a drug that slows his heart. After that he spends most films off to the side. Far From Home's last scene shows the real Fury relaxing on a beach that turns out to be a fake setting on a Skrull ship in space, while Talos covers for him on Earth. Source: Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014); Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019), post-credits scene

Secret Invasion fills in some of the gap. Fury has been working from S.A.B.E.R., a space station, since returning from the Blip, and he comes back to Earth to deal with Skrulls hiding in high places. Source: Secret Invasion, episode 1 (Disney+, 2023)

The evidence board

  1. Fury says he can't eat diagonally cut toast.

    Captain Marvel, Fury and Carol test each other
  2. Fury eats a diagonally cut sandwich at the Barton farm.

    Avengers: Age of Ultron, Barton farmhouse
  3. Talos and Soren posed as Fury and Maria Hill through Far From Home.

    Spider-Man: Far From Home, post-credits scene

The case against

  • The poster admitted the bread did not look toasted and filed the post under humor.

Still open

Far From Home proved Talos stood in for Fury once, but no film says it happened from 2014.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on Reddit in 2019-03 (r/marvelstudios). Covered by SYFY, CinemaBlend, WhatCulture and We Got This Covered.

More theories about these films

The open question

How many of Fury's big MCU moments would you still trust if a Skrull might have played them?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space