MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Confirmed

Rhodey has been a Skrull for years

Secret Invasion revealed Rhodey was a Skrull; fans then dug for when the real one was replaced, and the director said Civil War.

What fans think

Secret Invasion's episode 4 shows that James Rhodes is a Skrull impostor. Fans had already noticed him calling Fury 'Nick' instead of 'Fury' when firing him, a slip they read as Fury realizing the truth. Most first assumed he was swapped after Endgame, but the finale shows the real Rhodey in a hospital gown, struggling to walk, which fans tied to his paralysis in Captain America: Civil War. Director Ali Selim answered 'Yep' when asked whether Rhodey was replaced back then.

Behind the theory

The airport fight in Civil War ends with Vision's beam hitting War Machine by mistake. Rhodey falls from the sky and breaks his back, and Tony builds him braces to walk. That injury is why fans saw the real Rhodey's weak legs in Secret Invasion's finale as a clue to when he was taken. Source: Captain America: Civil War (2016), the airport fight and the Avengers compound

The evidence board

  1. Rhodey calls Fury 'Nick' just before firing him, which sounds wrong for him.

    Secret Invasion, Rhodey's meeting where he fires Fury
  2. The rescued Rhodey wears a hospital gown and can barely walk.

    Secret Invasion, episode 6

The case against

  • Selim also said it would take 'a librarian' to sort out every Rhodey scene, and Marvel has not given an official timeline.

Confirmed

Episode 4 shows he is a Skrull, and director Ali Selim pointed to Civil War as the start.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on Reddit and X in 2023-06 (Twitter). Covered by Inverse, /Film, The Digital Fix, Daily Dot and Yahoo.

More theories about these films

The open question

If Rhodey was a Skrull since Civil War, which of his big moments since then still count as his?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space