MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

Bucky will be the next Captain America

When Steve retires, his best friend Bucky takes the shield, like in the comics.

What fans think

In the comics Bucky took over as Captain America after Steve's death, so many fans expected the same in Endgame. Instead old Steve gives the shield to Sam Wilson while Bucky watches and nods. Sebastian Stan said Bucky becoming Cap 'makes no sense,' and the Russos said Sam deserved it. Sam carries the shield in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier and Captain America: Brave New World.

Behind the theory

The comic run fans had in mind is Ed Brubaker's. He brought Bucky back as the Winter Soldier in 2005, then had Steve shot dead on the courthouse steps after the superhero Civil War in 2007. Bucky took up the shield and a new costume in 2008 and stayed Captain America until Steve returned. Source: Captain America vol. 5 #1 (2005), #25 (2007) and #34 (2008), by Ed Brubaker and Steve Epting

The MCU sent Bucky down another road. In The Falcon and the Winter Soldier he works through his list of people to make amends to, and in Thunderbolts* he has become a congressman before he joins the new team. Source: The Falcon and the Winter Soldier (Disney+, 2021); Thunderbolts* (2025)

The evidence board

  1. Bucky took the role in the comics.

    Comics (not film)
  2. The Endgame writers said Bucky as the next Cap was 'Considered, but quickly dropped.'

    Behind the scenes of Avengers: Endgame (writers' tweet)

The case against

  • Old Steve hands the shield to Sam on the bench by the lake.

Debunked

Steve gives the shield to Sam at the end of Endgame.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

We could not find the first post; fans have talked about it since 2014-2019. Covered by CinemaBlend, NME, Looper and MovieWeb; the cast and directors were asked about it.

More theories about these films

The open question

Was Sam the right choice for the shield, or did Bucky deserve a turn?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space