MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

The snapped heroes are alive inside the Soul Stone

Everyone dusted by Thanos is trapped in the Soul Stone, waiting to be let out.

What fans think

After the snap, Thanos visits an orange dreamlike place and talks to young Gamora, the same color as the Soul Stone. Fans reasoned that all snap victims went there too, as in the Infinity Gauntlet comics, so Endgame would free them from the stone. Instead the Avengers use time travel to get the stones and Hulk snaps everyone back, with no 'Soul World' rescue.

Behind the theory

The comic fans leaned on is Jim Starlin's The Infinity Gauntlet from 1991. Thanos wipes out half of all life, and the heroes who are left fight him in space. The Soul Gem holds a world of its own, Soul World, where Adam Warlock lived in earlier Starlin comics. In the end Nebula takes the gauntlet and undoes the snap, so readers expected a rescue from inside a stone. Source: The Infinity Gauntlet #1 to #6 (1991), by Jim Starlin, George Perez and Ron Lim

Endgame chose time instead. Five years pass, the team takes the stones from the past, and when the Hulk snaps, the dusted come back where they were with no time gone for them. Peter wakes on Titan, and Strange arrives through portals with the armies of Wakanda and Asgard. Source: Avengers: Endgame (2019), the second snap and the final battle

The evidence board

  1. Thanos talks to young Gamora in an orange space.

    Avengers: Infinity War, after the snap
  2. Joe Russo confirmed the young Gamora scene happens inside the Soul Stone, which fans stretched to cover everyone who was snapped.

    Avengers: Infinity War, after the snap

The case against

  • Time travel and a second snap, not a Soul World, undo the losses.

Debunked

Endgame brings the victims back with a new snap, not from inside the Soul Stone.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

We could not find the first post; fans have talked about it since 2018. Listed in GamesRadar, Stanford Daily and SYFY Endgame theory roundups; WatchMojo counts it among top wrong ones.

More theories about these films

The open question

Where did the snapped people go for five years, and do they remember anything?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space