MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Partly true

Strange's one winning future needed Tony to die

Doctor Strange saw that the only future where they win is the one where Tony sacrifices himself.

What fans think

In Infinity War, Strange looks at 14,000,605 futures and finds one win, then hands Thanos the Time Stone to save Tony. Fans argued Strange chose Tony because Tony's death was part of that single win. In Endgame's final battle, Strange raises one finger to Tony, Tony understands, and snaps. A popular r/FanTheories post went further and argued Tony also had to die because he caused trouble in futures after Thanos.

Behind the theory

Strange chose his words with care on Titan. He had said he would let Tony and Peter die before handing over the Time Stone, then gives it to Thanos to stop him from killing Tony. Just before he turns to dust, he tells Tony it was the only way. Endgame's title comes from Strange's line that they are in the endgame now. Source: Avengers: Infinity War (2018), Titan

In Endgame's last battle, Strange holds the portals open and watches the gauntlet move across the field. When Tony looks at him, he lifts one finger, and Tony takes the stones and snaps. Source: Avengers: Endgame (2019), the final battle

The evidence board

  1. Strange holds up one finger to Tony just before the snap (Benedict Cumberbatch improvised it).

    Avengers: Endgame, final battle
  2. Strange trades the Time Stone for Tony's life on Titan.

    Avengers: Infinity War, Titan

The case against

  • The Russos only confirmed Strange lived each future; they never said Tony's death was required in every version of the win.

Partly true

Joe Russo said Tony knows the solution means snapping and dying; the extra 'Tony caused later trouble' version is not confirmed.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on r/FanTheories in 2021. The original post. Covered by Inverse, Looper and BGR; the 'one finger' moment is one of Endgame's most talked-about beats.

More theories about these films

The open question

If Strange knew Tony had to die, should he have told him?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space