MCU Easter Eggs

My Marvel
Advertisement
Ad space

← All fan theories

Debunked

Kate's mom's fiance Jack is the real villain

Jack Duquesne was a smiling swordsman with a dead uncle, and the show seemed to point right at him.

What fans think

In Hawkeye, Kate Bishop's mother is engaged to Jack Duquesne, who fences, acts shady and inherits after his uncle Armand is found dead. Comic readers knew Jack as the Swordsman, and fans suspected him of the murder, of the Tracksuit Mafia, even of being a fake Ronin. A writer at The Cosmic Circus called him a red herring. The finale shows Kate's mother Eleanor working with the Kingpin; Jack was innocent.

Behind the theory

Comic fans had a reason to watch Jack. The Swordsman first appeared in 1965, and in the comics he worked in the circus that raised Clint and trained him before turning to crime. Tony Dalton played Jack as a cheerful rich man with a sword collection, which made fans more suspicious, not less. Source: The Avengers #19 (1965), by Stan Lee and Don Heck; Hawkeye (Disney+, 2021)

The finale clears him. Kate learns that her mother Eleanor had Kazi kill Armand Duquesne, and that she had been working with Fisk. Eleanor is arrested, and Jack joins the fight at the Rockefeller Center party on Kate's side. Source: Hawkeye, episode 6 (Disney+, 2021)

The evidence board

  1. Jack is a skilled fencer who seems to benefit from Armand's death.

    Hawkeye, episodes 1 and 2
  2. A Reddit theory argued Jack, not Clint, killed Maya's father while posing as Ronin.

    Hawkeye, episode 3

The case against

  • Episode 5 shows Eleanor meeting Fisk, and Jack ends the series cleared.

Debunked

Eleanor, not Jack, was working with Kingpin.

Do you buy it?

One tap. No account needed.

Where it started

Started on Reddit in 2021-11. Covered by Looper, The Cosmic Circus and Inverse.

More theories about these films

The open question

Was Jack the show's best red herring, or did it treat him unfairly?

Sources

Discussion

Advertisement
Ad space